Review By Goat Scrote
If Franz Kafka had ever had children, this is
the kind of bedtime story he would tell them. Yes, this is a cartoon with
lovable talking animals in it, but no, you absolutely should not show this film
to young children unless you're doing illicit psychological experimentation
involving childhood trauma [http://www.kindertrauma.com/?p=773 ]. There's
animal torture, some human gore, dark social commentary, and a whole lot of
heavy existential seeking, and no happy endings for anybody. The movie is way
too honest to give easy answers to the questions it raises. Even adults might
have a little trouble digesting such a heavy mental meal.
These dogs only wish they could be as lucky as
Bambi's mother and die quickly. If you thought the animated violence in
"Watership Down" was traumatic for the tots, you should know that
"Plague Dogs" ups the ante considerably. Both films are based on
books by Richard Adams, and are written, directed, and produced by Martin
Rosen. It's not surprising that there are similarities, but where
"Watership Down" tells an essentially hopeful story about loss and
renewal, Plague Dogs tells a relentlessly hopeless story about senseless
cruelty and pointless tragedy. It's a good movie, and using cute animals to say
something serious is one of the oldest storytelling traditions there is, but
Plague Dogs is so bleak and sad in places that I find it genuinely painful to
watch!
For the trivia buffs, dialogue from this movie
is sampled by Skinny Puppy in their anti-vivisection song "Testure",
and a clip from the movie can be seen in the background of the music video.
[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qtySNoe0gMw].
The story opens in an animal testing facility
where we witness a little slice of animated Hell on Earth. It's a dismal picture
of institutional cruelty with little discernible purpose. Some of the lab dogs
like Rowf (Christopher Benjamin) are locked inside a water-filled tank and
forced to swim until they become exhausted and drown, only to be resuscitated,
put back in their tiny cages, and made to do it all over again the next day.
Other dogs like Snitter (John Hurt) subjected to experimental brain surgery.
"Why do they do it?" he wonders in bewildered pain, "I'm not a
bad dog."
Inside Snitter's mind |
When a cage door isn't latched properly, Snitter
and Rowf take the opportunity to escape.
Snitter has odd hallucinations and seizures from his surgery, and he is
ridden with guilt for his role in the accidental death of his former master,
but he still has a basic trust of human beings. Rowf is less certain about the
goodness of mankind, but together the two seek a new master. Their innocent
attempts to connect with humans go wrong every time. They go to town but get
spooked when they see a butcher in his bloody white apron, so similar to the
doctors at the lab. They see a shepherd and his sheepdogs and try to fit in by
chasing the sheep, which fails to win them any affection.
In a world that seems endlessly hostile, they
finally find something of a friend out in the wild. The Tod (James Bolam) is a
wily fox who makes a deal with the dogs. He will teach them to survive as
"wild animals" and they will help him get bigger prey, like sheep.
Unfortunately, their success at sheep-killing just gets them hunted by the
locals.
Things finally seem about to take a turn for the
better when Snitter encounters a kind man in the woods - a new master! As
Snitter finally realizes his dream and scampers into the man's arms, however,
fate betrays him. His paw snags the trigger of the man's shotgun and the man's face
is suddenly gone with a boom and a big red splash. This is the most brutal
scene in the movie and it kicks me right in the nuts every time.
raspberry jam is pouring out of my face! |
Snitter's spirit is broken. "I'm bad,"
he despairs. Things don't get any cheerier for the strange little pack, either.
Winter comes and their ribs are showing. A hunter stalking them falls to his
death and the starving dogs eat him. When the hunter is found ripped to shreds
it doesn't help the fugitive dogs' public image. Reporters have started
stirring up sentiment against the dogs and the lab. The lab directors kept the
escape quiet to avoid embarrassment but this seems downright sinister when
rumors start that the dogs might be infected with the bubonic plague. The
absurdity of the situation reaches its peak when escalating public outcry leads
politicians to call in the military to deal with the two tormented, weak,
confused stray dogs.
Where are those Snausages we ordered? |
The Tod proves to be a true friend when he
sacrifices himself to help Rowf and Snitter escape onto a train car. The dogs
reach the sea as soldiers close in, and flee together into the water in sort of
a canine "Thelma and Louise" moment. At first Snitter hallucinates
that the sun shining through the ocean fog is an island, a place where they can
finally find peace. As they swim on and on into the fog Snitter realizes that
the island was just another illusion from his damaged brain and he despairs.
Rowf, the veteran of the water-tank, urges Snitter to keep swimming. The two
dogs vanish together into the fog, never to be seen again. So did Snitter give
up? Does Rowf drown in the end, after all? Is the whole world just a big
version of the torture tank, where every living thing is drowned and
resuscitated over and over for reasons we can never comprehend, bereft of any
hope of escape except one final plunge into cold and darkness? I ain't sayin',
and neither does the movie. As the credits roll, though, the fog slowly parts,
and there is a smudge in the distance that might be the hoped-for island. It
seems impossibly far off, too far for a couple of exhausted dogs to reach, but
the island is there... a tiny sliver of possibility.
Highly Recommended!
Highly Recommended!
Do they make it out OK? |
Paramilitary Dog termination squad |
No comments:
Post a Comment